Home Tom's Sailboat Tom's Clan

November 4, 2005

Is This the Death of Publisher Funded Original IP?

Filed under: Thoughts and Rants — Tom B @ 3:50 pm

The recent announcement of the formation of BioWare/Pandemic Studios, an alliance between BioWare, Pandemic and Elevation Partners, raises a serious question…Is traditional publisher funding of original IP dead? I suspect the answer to that question is a resounding YES! It is difficult to think of a major publisher that is investing or even interested in original IP. And then only if it is coming out of one of the top independent studios or a spinoff of top tier developers. Publishers are more comfortable with licensed properties and sequels, and rightly so. Even a bad sequel will sell through to an existing fan base. But no matter how cool you know your original IP is, there is no way for the marketing monkeys at the publishers to get a retail commitment to an initial order for a game that no one in the Wal Mart buyer’s office has ever heard of.

Fortunately, publishers have been charging a heavy premium for their funding, often requiring as much as 35% of the net receipts be allocated to the up front funding of the development and taking the IP in the process as well., just to justify the advances. However, if you look at the actually value of the money it really only represents 20% or so of the risk model. The other 15%, as well as the IP rights, are in effect a bonus to the publisher because no one else is willing to fund the development costs. So while a 50/50 marketing and distribution deal is no problem with a fully funded game, a 20% for a publisher funded game is out of the question, even with the IP. I smell an opportunity.

Seamus Blackley has been pitching this sort of model for years. Let publishers do what they do best…market and distribute games. And let those who understand finance fund the development. Well it looks to me like that’s a big part of the Bioware/Pandemic super. studio model and certainly the reason why it was facilitated by the capital group that has $300M to put into the pot. It will sure be interesting to see how things work out as both of these studios understand the value of retained IP and have a talent for repeated hit on original games. A very sweet combination!

1 Comment »

  1. What will be interesting to track, as well, is how the Bioware corporate culture grows, changes, morphs now that this company is an industry “biggie.” I really admire the culture that Ray and Greg have created with their organization. Sure there are those who grumble (if you don’t like crunch time, you are in the wrong business), but looking at them from the outside and talking to the folks who have shown the company loyalty and continue to sing their praises speaks to the fact that it is possible to exist and grow in this nutty business with your integrity intact. I really believe in the team-based model, and I am curious to see how, or if, an organization can grow and still maintain that team focus.

    Comment by Opus — November 9, 2005 @ 1:59 pm

RSS feed for comments on this post.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.


Powered by WordPress. Theme by H P Nadig